Source: prismnet.com, by Barry Chamish
- Just previous to the evening of November 4, 1995, Prime Minister
Yitzhak Rabin was a very worried man. His peace process with the PLO
was not going well with the Israeli public. The latest poll in the
daily newspaper Maariv showed that 78% of the public wanted the
process stopped until a national referendum was held to decide whether
to continue or not. Only 18% of Israelis trusted Rabin enough to have
him carry on his diplomacy without a public referendum. Rabin couldn't
step out in public without being heckled. His most humiliating moment
came in August when he was introduced at a soccer game and
40,000 fans jeered him in unison.
But that evening would be different. A coalition of left wing
political parties and youth movements had organized a rally in support
of him and Rabin knew that, for a change, he would be surrounded by
thousands of well wishers.
Which made his murder that evening doubly unexpected. It all seemed so
easy. At 9:15, Rabin ad-libbed a speech before 100,000 supporters
gathered at a square outside Tel Aviv's city hall. A half hour later,
he walked down the steps of the stage into the "sterile" area below
where his car awaited him. Here he would be safe from threat because
no one but approved security personnel were supposed to be there.
But something was very wrong in the parking lot below. The area, far
from being sterile, was crawling with unauthorized personnel. If Rabin
had been alert he would have noticed that things were not looking very
right at all. First of all, he should have thought, where's the
ambulance? There was always an ambulance stationed near his car when
he made public appearances, yet this evening it was nowhere to be
seen. Then he should have asked, where are the policemen? Dozens of
policemen should have providing security but only a few were in sight.
The parking area was almost totally dark whereas it was standard
security procedure to illuminate his walking route.
But Rabin seemed buoyed by the success of his speech and
uncharacteristically walked alone, unaccompanied by his wife, Leah,
toward his car. A few seconds before he reached his vehicle, a
security agent of the General Security Services (Shabak) who was
supposed to cover his rear stepped back, stopped and permitted an
assassin, Yigal Amir, to get three clear shots at Rabin's back.
As soon as the bullets were fired, a Shabak agent yelled, "Srak.
Srak," or "they're blanks, they're blanks," while another agent told
Rabin's wife Leah a few moments later not to worry because "the shots
were blanks." The agents next to Rabin pounced on the killer and
cuffed him. His first words after being apprehended were, "Why are you
handcuffing me? I did my job. Now it is time to do yours." The first
question the Shabak agents asked the assassin was, "Didn't you fire
blanks?"
Since there was no ambulance, Rabin was driven by car to a nearby
hospital. The car was not equipped with a radio so neither the
policemen manning roadblocks cleared the way nor were hospital staff
awaiting the victim. A few minutes later, dozens of reporters received
messages from a spokesman from an unknown group called Jewish
Vengeance promising to get Rabin next time. After the announcement of
his death, the spokesman called the reporters back, retracting the
earlier announcement and taking responsibility for the murder.
At 11:15 P.M., Rabin aide Eitan Haber, holding what he claimed was a
bloody songsheet Rabin had sang from at the rally, announced the Prime
Minister's death. That task done, Haber rushed to Jerusalem and
cleaned out the files of Rabin's defence ministry office. He
apparently couldn't wait until the next morning and later told a
reporter from the weekly magazine Kol Ha'ir that "I wanted to be sure
the files were donated to the archives of the Israel Defence Forces
(IDF)."
WHAT HAPPENED TO YIGAL AMIR IN RIGA?
The accused killer Yigal Amir had served honorably in the elite Golani
Brigade of the Israel Defence Forces and immediately after his release
was sent to Riga, Latvia in the spring of l993 on some sort of mission
by a covert branch of the Prime Minister's Office, the Liaison
Department.
Founded in 1953 to educate and rescue Jews from behind the Iron
Curtain, the Liaison Department had become a nest of spies over the
years. As the daily newspaper Haaretz reported a few weeks after Rabin
was killed: "The Liaison Department conducts its own diplomacy and has
its own private agenda."
Amir was an activist for reputedly the most radical anti-government
organization of all, Eyal. The head of Eyal, Avishai Raviv was filmed
by Israeli TV a month and a half before leading an induction ceremony
in which new members vowed to kill anyone who "sold out the Land of
Israel." If Eyal was really a secret organization why did the members
allow themselves to be filmed by Israel TV and expose themselves to
the public?
A week after Rabin was killed, on November 12, journalist Amnon
Abramovich revealed on Israel TV that Eyal was set up by the Shabak to
provoke and trap right wing radicals and its leader, Avishai Raviv was
an agent whose code name was "Champagne", referring to the bubbles of
incitement he raised.
Raviv was an agitator on the campus of Bar Ilan University, where Amir
studied. He befriended Amir and encouraged him to organize study
weekends in Hebron. As it turned out, Raviv was no newcomer to the
Shabak. Back in 1987 he was supposed to be expelled from Tel Aviv
University for his radical activities by the dean, Itamar Rabinovitch,
who until just recently was Rabin's chief negotiator with the Syrians.
Then-Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir ordered his aide Yossi Achimeir to
personally intervene on Raviv's behalf. Thus Raviv was not recruited
after Rabin came to power.
Eyal had only two members, Raviv and Erin Agelbo. They shared a rented
apartment in the Hebron suburb of Kiryat Arba in the same building
where Baruch Goldstein once resided. But Agelbo, it turned out, was
not just an ordinary, everyday extremist either. After the weekly
magazine Yerushalyim printed his picture, a reader recognized him as a
Jerusalem policeman who trained her in weapons use during a stint in
the civil guard. Lo and behold a link between the assassination and
the police emerged. The Jerusalem Police Department owned up and
admitted Agelbo was a "former policeman who was fired for his radical
activities in 1994."
Shortly after the murder, the Israeli media began exposing some very
incriminating evidence. The most serious of all was that Yigal Amir
was a Shabak agent. The first to make the accusation publicly was
Professor Michael Hersigor, a left wing political science professor at
Tel Aviv University. On November 11, a week after the killing, he told
a reporter from Yediot Achronot, "The murder of the prime minister has
no rational explanation. There is no explaining the breakdown and no
telling what happened. But in my opinion it would be advisable to seek
the connection between Amir and the Shabak. It's possible there was a
conspiracy. It turns out the murderer was in the Shabak when he
travelled to Riga. He was supplied with false documents with which to
receive a gun license. It sounds like he had connections to the Shabak
at the time of the murder."
The heat was turned up when Alex Fishman of Yediot Achronot reported
that Amir was trained by the Shabak in Riga. Soon after, Army Radio
broadcasted an interview with Rabbi Benny Elon, a leader of the Jewish
settlement movement, who said, "The Shabak was responsible for the
founding and funding of Eyal and its leader Avishai Raviv. I claim
that the Shabak knew Eyal's every move before the assassination and
that the Shabak funded its activities."
With the facts closing in, the government embarked on a sloppy cover-
up of Amir's Riga days. In order; the government's press office
announced that Amir, who spoke no Latvian and had no teaching
credentials, was a Hebrew teacher in Riga for five months. The head of
the Liaison Department, whose name was whited-out of a Maariv article,
then changed the story to read he was a teacher for two to three
months. After this, Minister of Internal Security, Moshe Shahal, told
Israel TV that Amir was a security guard in Riga for two months, which
was probably the closest version to the truth. Finally, running out of
ideas, the spokesperson of the Prime Minister, Aliza Goren, announced
in late December that the Prime Minister's Office is now certain Amir
was never in Riga and that any journalist writing so "was acting
irresponsibly." That ploy fell apart when the BBC filmed a copy of
Amir's passport with the letters CCCP clearly stamped in it.
But this wasn't the end of the story of the Prime Minister's strange
Liaison Office. In the months prior to the assassination, the State
Comptroller's Office initiated an investigation of profound corruption
at the Liaison Office and the unexplained disappearance of a great
deal of money in the C.I.S. In late l992, Rabin announced he was
considering closing down the Liaison Office for good.
THE KEMPLER FILM
A co-called amateur photographer, Ronnie Kempler, filmed the murder of
Rabin. He had no camera of his own so borrowed one from his sister and
hung around on a balcony overlooking the parking lot for over an hour,
unquestioned. He claimed he had "an odd feeling" about Amir and
focused in on him for long periods of time.
His film clearly shows Amir signalling someone in the distance a few
minutes before the shooting and it captures the movement of an agent
who circled Rabin, took over the rear position and allowed Amir in to
take his shots. What the tape shows (albeit does not prove) is that
Yigal Amir pointed a gun at Yitzhak Rabin and shot at him. But what if
the bullets weren't real?
The amateur film of the Rabin assassination has since been examined by
numerous people in frame by frame sequence and found to have been
sloppily cut and edited. The strangest part of it is Rabin's reaction
to being shot. Instead of lurching forward from the bullets, he
alertly turns back, seemingly aware of the events taking place.
Kempler works for the State Comptroller's Office. Even the most
skeptical Israeli had to ask why the fateful moment wasn't captured on
film by a car salesman, postal carrier or computer programmer. Why was
he employed by the very office that was investigating the former
employer of the assassin?
At the very moment Rabin was shot, Kempler stopped filming. He told
Israel's Second TV channel interviewer Rafi Reshef that it was because
"he had seen enough." Yet he told another journalist he had dropped
the camera, and another, that a policeman told him to stop shooting.
When the beta film was converted for viewing on national
television, the technician who did the transcribing claimed that the
sound of the agent yelling "blanks, blanks" was removed.
Other than one short appearance on Channel 2 after the film was aired,
Ronnie Kempler has never been quoted publicly in any newspaper-
anywhere.
THE SHAMGAR COMMISSION
The testimony of policemen at the Shamgar Commission hampered a clean
cover-up. While the Shabak chose to exonerate the police of all
responsibility for the murder, the chief of the Tel Aviv Police
Department, Gabi Lest, testified that his men were supposed to secure
the sterile area but were not stationed by Rabin's security men. Those
policemen were shocked to see that the Shabak officers were not in
place.
What those few officers in place testified to the Shamgar Commission
compromises the lone gunman theory, which the Commission, personally
appointed Prime Minister Shimon Peres, eventually ruled was the case.
Officers Sergei and Boaz testified that they saw Amir talking with a
tall, dark man in a tee shirt who he appeared to know about a half
hour before the shooting. Sargent Saar testified that he saw Amir's
brother Hagai, who was later charged with supplying the bullets for
the assassination, near the crime scene shortly before the murder.
Officer Sharabi testified that, "A man who we knew by face as an anti-
Rabin demonstrator rushed at Rabin, shook his hand and left."
Sergei became suspicious of the whole atmosphere and specifically of
Amir. He asked another officer who Amir was and was told he was
working undercover. The police claimed that Amir got into the sterile
area when he presented government credentials given to him by the
Liaison Office.
Thus the Shabak allowed Amir, who had been filmed being taken away
kicking from a demonstration at Efrat by the Shabak two weeks earlier,
another known demonstrator, Amir's brother who supposedly was carrying
bullets, an unknown film maker, and a mysterious man wearing a tee
shirt to roam at will in an area that was meant to be cordoned off to
unauthorized personnel.
RECONSTRUCTING THE MURDER
There are basically only two explanations for Rabin's assassination.
One is that the Shabak, one of the world's most respected security
organizations, is totally incompetent. The other is that agents on the
scene allowed the assassination to take place. Probably with Rabin's
knowledge, the Shabak set up Amir.
The theme of the gathering on the fateful night was, "No To Violence."
Amir was to have shot Rabin with blanks, Rabin was to have
miraculously escaped an assassination attempt and then climbed back on
the stage with a stirring speech, written by his close aide, Eitan
Haber. The public would react with revulsion against the attempted
assassination by an extremist right winger and the government could
justify a crackdown against opponents of the peace process.
WHAT DOES AMIR KNOW?
Consider the story of Shabak agent Yoav Kuriel who is widely believed
to have been the agent who yelled "they're blanks, they're blanks."
The night of Rabin's murder, his body was taken to Ichilov Hospital
and its organs were removed. The government claimed he committed
suicide and buried him in a closed funeral at Hayarkon Cemetary
outside of Tel Aviv. Traffic was diverted for ninety minutes while the
funeral took place. Maariv investigative journalist David Ronen
succeeded in tracking down Kuriel's death certificate. The hospital,
in a blatant disregard for procedure, left out the reason for death.
One day during his trial when Amir was seated in court he screamed to
the reporters, "Why don't you print the story about the murdered
bodyguard." He was asked which one. "The one who yelled the bullets
are blanks." In theory Amir was being kept in solitary confinement
with no access to the news. How did he know the story? And Amir wasn't
finished. He added,"I know enough to bring down the whole regime. The
whole business has been a charade. The entire system is rotten. I will
be forgiven when people know the whole story."
If that outburst was for public consumption, it was certainly
consistent with what he has been saying privately. On November 29,
l995, according to a report published by Maariv in early January '96,
he complained to the police officer taking testimony, "They're going
to kill me in here."
"Nonsense," replied the officer.
"You don't believe me, well I'm telling you it was a
conspiracy. I didn't know I was going to kill Rabin."
"What do you mean? You pulled the trigger, it's that simple."
"Then why didn't Raviv report me? He knew I was going to do it
and he didn't stop me? And why wasn't I shot to save Rabin?"
WHO KILLED YITZHAK RABIN?
By the early spring of 1996 new evidence led to the proposition that
Yigal Amir shot blanks while Rabin was murdered with real bullets
inside his car, not by the blanks that Amir fired.
On May 3, l996, Yigal Amir's lawyers appealed his conviction to the
Supreme Court arguing that it had not proved that his shots actually
killed Rabin. It included the testimony of Dr. Skolnick of Ichilov
Hospital who operated on Rabin and claims his wounds were not
consistent with the official story that Rabin was shot from a meter
away by Amir. Skolnick explained that the size of the wound and the
pattern of burn and powder marks were those of someone shot from point
blank.
By mid-May twelve doctors and staff who were on duty when Rabin was
brought in were receiving anonymous death threats. In June, a closed
door session of the Supreme Court heard testimony from a cab driver.
On the day Amir was convicted, his passenger showed him an ID card
from Ichilov Hospital which identified him as a pathologist. He told
the driver that Amir's conviction was a scam and that Rabin's wounds
were from point blank shots.
Amir's lawyers pointed out that the bullets may have been tampered
with since there are no record of what happened to them between the
time they were removed from Rabin's body on the night of November 4th
and the time they were delivered to the Abu Kabir Forensics Institute
at noon on November 5th.
The medical reports indicated that Rabin was killed by a bullet fired
from a gun against his flesh- not from five feet away.
Amir's attorneys cited the evidence of police ballistics expert Baruch
Glatstein who said his laboratory tests of Rabin's clothing showed
that the first bullet to hit him was fired from a distance of less
than 25 cm., while the second was fired with the gun actually touching
his clothing. Glatstein pointed out that the marks made by the second
bullet could only be made by a gun fired while touching the clothing.
Glatstein also examined the shirt of Rabin's bodyguard, Yoram Rubin,
and found traces of lead and copper in the bullet wounds. According to
forensic evidence gathered by Glatstein, the bullets which wounded
Rubin could not have been fired from Yigal Amir's gun. Amir's bullets
were made of pure copper while Glatstein found traces of lead mixed
with copper in the bullet hole in Rubin's shirt.
One of the very first media reports on the murder was an eyewitness
account given to Israel TV by Miriam Oren. She said when she saw Rabin
get into the car "he did not look at all like he was shot. He climbed
in on his own." When Kempler's film begins again after the shooting it
shows Rabin's car speeding off. Just before the car leaves the back
passenger door (Rabin entered the car through the rear driver's side
followed by Rubin) closes. Someone was already in the car waiting for
Rabin and as the Prime Minister entered, grabbed the car door and shut
it from the inside.
Amir's appeal was also based on the testimony of dozens of eye-
witnesses who testified that Amir was never close enough to Rabin to
have fired these shots. The eyewitnesses say that the gunshots had an
odd, distinctive sound, whereas tests of Amir's gun showed that its
sound was perfectly normal. In July, police officer Yossi Smadja was
quoted in Maariv as saying that he was almost next to the
assassination site and heard five shots, three clear and two muffled.
What these people heard were the muffled shots of the bullets that
killed Rabin coming from inside the car. Amir told the police
immediately after the event that he had put nine bullets in his gun.
Since four bullets were fired at Rabin, two which hit him, one which
hit Yoram Rubin, and one which missed both men but was later found at
the site, there should have been five bullets left in Amir's gun.
However, there were eight.
Then there is the testimony of Shimon Peres who saw Rabin's body in
the hospital. He claimed in Yediot Ahronot in late September that
Rabin's forehead was swollen and bruised, he thought from being pushed
on the pavement after he was shot. This is in direct contradiction to
the eyewitness report of Miriam Oren who was beside Rabin after Amir
pulled the trigger. She told Israel Television news moments after the
incident that Rabin walked into the car under his own power. Where,
and how then, did the bruises that Peres claims he saw occur?
Finally, there is the indisputable proof offered unintentionally by
Rabin's aide Eitan Haber. While Rabin was being operated on at Ichilov
Hospital, for reasons unexplained to this day, Haber rifled through
his suit and shirt pockets looking for something and pulled out the
songsheet Rabin had held at the rally. Haber produced it for the
cameras as he announced Rabin's death and it clearly shows a bullet
hole through the bloodstains. Unless Rabin put it in a non-existent
back pocket of his suit, he was shot from the front.
On September 20, two Israeli newspapers printed interviews with most
unexpected subtle advocates of the conspiracy thesis. After nine
months of silence Shlomo Levy gave an interview to Yerushalayim. Levy
was an associate of Amir's who was a soldier in the Intelligence
Brigade of the IDF. After hearing Amir's threats to kill Rabin, he
reported them to his commander who told him to go to the police. The
police took his testimony very seriously on July 6, 1995 and
transferred it to the Shabak where it was ignored until three days
after the assassination.
The report concludes, "Levy's was only one of a number of reports the
Shabak ignored about Amir...The fact that the Shabak let the reports
gather dust until Rabin was murdered lends credence to numerous
conspiracy theories."
Levy was asked, "If you did the right thing, why have you been hiding
in your home out of fear?" He replied,"The Shabak is big and powerful
and I'm a little guy. The assassination is an open wound with them and
who knows how they'd react if I let myself be interviewed."
On the same day, Rabin's son Yuval was interviewed in Yediot Ahronot.
Asked if he believed his father was killed in a conspiracy, a question
that said much about the public's interest, he replied, "I can't say
yes or no. It's not hard to accept it... One thing is certain, no one
was punished. The worst that happened to any Shabak agent was he lost
his job."
Considering the evidence, Yitzhak Rabin was not killed by Yigal Amir.
It's possible that most of Rabin's security guards and most likely
Rabin himself, thought it was going to be an elaborate plan to catch
the "right wing radical," Yigal Amir, red handed. Amir himself may
have been drugged or duped into believing that his bullets were real
and that he really did kill Rabin. He may have be programed to take
the blame.
Whoever was behind this coup also had the help of the Shamgar
Commission whose conclusions merely reinforced the manufactured media
image in the Israeli public's mind that radical Jewish extremism was
responsible for the murder. The cover up was as insidious as the
crime.
----------------
Barry Chamish is the editor of Inside Israel, a political intelligence
report on Israeli affairs
https://www.prismnet.com/~patrik/rabin.htm